Now past the midway point in the season and following an
episode full of big reveals and important events: this episode felt slightly anticlimactic,
but in a good way, because I for one am still bruised from the loss of Hodor…
so naturally we had to pick up where we left off with Meera and Bran in the
blizzard. Bran is having a series of visions that are all jumbled
between the past/present/future; we catch glimpses of familiar scenes (Bran’s
fall from the tower at Winterfell, the Red Wedding, the terrifying
transformation of Crastor’s baby into a White Walker) along with some we know
happened but haven’t witnessed from the past (King Aerys screaming "burn them all!" just before he's
slain by Jamie Lannister). Poor Meera got as far away as she could but she and
Bran are about to become wight-fodder, when - COLDHANDS SHOWS UP!?!?!?!?
For us book readers, this is huge – Coldhands was completely left out of the
show despite his rather large role in the books. Even more shocking - COLDHANDS
IS UNCLE BENJEN STARK!!!! In the after-episode commentary, Weiss and Benioff explicitly use the words "Coldhands Benjen" so I'm not just speculating here. Last seen back in Episode 3 of Season 1, Benjen has
been MIA north of the Wall – fake news about Benjen was how the traitorous Alliser
Thorn lured Jon Snow to his death last season. We find out Uncle Benjen was
nearly killed by a White Walker years ago, only to be rescued by a CotF’s
magic. This is confounding for the Song
of Ice and Fire fandom because GRRM has dismissed the fan theory that
Benjen Stark was Coldhands - so either he was lying, or the two characters have
been merged for the purposes of the show (possibly to placate fans of this theory, even if it won't be fulfilled in the books, as GRRM has indicated).
Either way we learn from Benjen that Bran is now the Three Eyed Raven, and that
he must master his abilities before the Night King finds them (Thanks, Captain
Obvious).
Cut to sunny Horn Hill - Gilly gets to meet Sam’s family in
his absolutely gorgeous ancestral home. As expected, Lady Tarly and sister Talla are
lovely welcoming women, pleased to meet Sam’s “mistress” and “bastard child.” Excitingly
for me, Gilly gets the finest makeover to ever happen in the history of the
Seven Kingdoms for dinner. On the outset, little Sam and Gilly seem to have hit
the jackpot – escaping gruesome Craster’s Keep for this Westerosi paradise!? But
then we actually meet Lord Tarly.
Suddenly Craster’s title as “Worst Father on the Planet” is much less secure. Lady
Talla cheerfully quips to Gilly: “I think our father could learn a thing or two
from your father!” which makes the audience cringe
from a double whammy of circumstantial irony.
Randyl Tarly is a sneering evil fucker who despises Sam, his
oldest son, because he is academic and intellectual instead of athletic and
violent. He’s the Westerosi equivalent of the has-been quarterback who belittles
his son for being better at computers than at football. He gleans from Gilly’s
defense of her man that she’s a Wilding and cruelly berates Sam for knocking up
a “Wilding Whore.” Lady Tarley checks out and chastises her asswipe husband,
talking Talla and Gilly with her. Sam seems cowardly in his silent non-response,
but in truth his father could easily have kicked Gilly and Lil Sam out on the
street – so Sam doesn’t stand up to his father, and Gilly earns the
award for best girl friend of the year for not holding it against him. She
laments: "I'm angry that horrible people can treat good people that way
and get away with it." Oh, Gilly- this is Game of Thrones; that was getting off easy! However, Sam gets about
10 feet towards the Citadel before reversing his entire decision to keep
Gilly/Lil Sam at Horn Hill. Sam is one of 3 genuinely good people left on this show
and he’s had enough of the way the world works: he steals Heartsbane (the Tarly’s
ancestral Valyrian steel sword) and is off with his lady love and his adopted
son, hopefully to a safe arrangement while he is in Maester school. I find it
heartwarming that Sam – the schlubbiest character we know, is the guy that lands
the semi-heroic romantic subplot.
Speaking of romance: Tommen finally gets to reunite with his
wife, who is looking cleaner and better kept since we saw her last with Loras
in the dungeons. She’s singing a different tune now: gone is the
fiery “Don’t give in!”- replaced with “I was only good at appearing to be good,
it wasn’t sincere!” Major laughs to Tommen’s insistence that Margaery is the
best person he knows – because in his case, he might be right! Sadly, she seems to have drunk the Sparrow’s
coolaid. Tsk tsk Margaery, I had such high hopes for you.
In Braavos, Arya watches gleefully as play-Joffrey dies at
his wedding – while everyone else admires Lady Crane's portrayal of Cersei. Arya
knows she’s doing Cersei waaaaaaay more justice than she deserves, but feels
badly that she has to kill the actress. She pours the poison into the rum
anyway, but before she can make her getaway Lady Crane pulls her aside! She
questions Arya about the show and her herself in a manner that makes it appear
that LC may be a Faceless Man in disguise – “do you like pretending to be other
people?” Arya expresses that Cersei would have ranted and raved at Joffrey’s
death, not been merely depressed; they share a sweet exchange about the nature
of acting/the shitty script of the play, and it seems she isn’t a spy for Jaqen.
Before LC can drink the poisoned rum Arya dashes the glass on the floor - and
guess who was watching in the shadows? The Waif – who reports back to Jaqen that
a Girl purposely failed her mission, and the Waif is dispatched to kill her.
Arya fetches Needle - effectively reclaiming her identity!!! and brings her
sword back to her bedroom; blows out the candle to await her inevitable
assassination in the darkness. Despite the machinations and creed of the House
of Black and White – life isn’t always so clear cut, as Arya has learned. She
has chosen a different path now, as Arya Stark – hopefully she survives the
Waif to seek her vengeance in a more ethical way.
Back in Kingslanding, Jaime and Mace Tyrell meet up to march
on the Sept. Mace gives what he thinks
is a rousing speech but literally no one
cheered (Anticlimax #1). The Sparrow begins Margaery’s Walk of Shame pronouncement, and
the Tyrells storm the square with Olenna in tow. Jaime charges his horse up the
steps to face off with the High Sparrow, reminiscent of his former self as a
fearsome warrior, and a bloody massacre seems imminent – and then it all gets
thrown out the window, because Margaery has atoned for her sins already by
converting the King, who is paraded out like the stooge that he is: and Jaime
and Olenna know they have lost (Anticlimax #2). With the Crown under the full
influence of the High Sparrow, the great houses of Westeros are up shit creek:
religious zealotry will inevitably invite a new era of cleansing torture and
imprisonment for any nobles who the High Sparrow deems sinful – whether they
deserve it or not. At this point, a coup from Dany might actually be what’s
best for the people – who knows?
Uncle Jaime, for his crime, is stripped of his job as a Kings Guard. He will be sent to oversee a military excursion to the Riverlands, where as it turns out: The Blackfish has taken back Riverrun. Huge news! Littlefinger wasn’t full of shit! Walder Frey is shown for an expository 5 minutes berating his sons for their military blunders. They plan to use the Red Wedding’s groom, Edmure Tully, to broker a deal.
Jaime balks at his assignment, reluctant to leave Cersei, hoping to enlist Bronn to assassinate the High Sparrow for his crimes against the Lannisters. Cersei disagrees: she wants Jaime to go and take back that “silly little castle” to keep the peace. She is unconcerned about her upcoming trial because she has FrankenMountain to represent her in combat, and clearly has a pot boiler of a scheme in the works to make their enemies suffer, horribly.
THIS MEANS WE WILL MAYBE GET A BRIENNE/JAIME
REUNION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! They’re both now headed for Riverrun, albeit on opposing
sides of the Crown. #TeamTormund even though I hope J/B get to have a friendly
exchange before falling into battle.
At the end now, Dany stops weirdly for no apparent reason to
question Daario about how many ships she will need to take the Dothraki across
the Narrow Sea (1000 and more – funny, isn’t that about how many ships Yara and Theon
stole from Euron Greyjoy?) I stopped and rewound this part a bunch of times,
looking for any visual clues as to why – in the middle of a barren mountain
pass – Dany would hold up the progress of her army down to Meereen. There’s
nothing – no subtle shadows indicating what was to come. Anyway, Dany rides off
and the rest of the Horsemen are scratching their heads. She must have been
gone for more than what is considered a comfortable time, so Daario goes to follow her - and this bitch rides back in on Drogon –
who was conveniently hiding somewhere in this mountain range for Dany to spectacularly
make her reappearance. She gives an epic speech reminiscent of Khal Drogo’s
from Season One. She rallies the crowd, claiming she has chosen them ALL to be her Blood Riders, and they will fulfill her destiny to reclaim her throne across the sea!
This is another case of chosen identity for this episode; like Sam and Arya, Dany has decided to commit to her nature – she is a conqueror, not a ruler. As Daario said moments before, she isn’t meant to sit pretty in the high tower and reason with people – she’s meant to swoop in and take what is hers. However, unlike Sam and Arya – this isn’t an instance of embracing an ethical identity: maybe Dany isn’t the hero she believes herself to be. Can a conqueror ever be truly considered benevolent? I think she’s more like her Mad King father than she knows – it could easily have been Dany in Bran’s vision, commanding her minions to “burn them all!” instead of King Aerys.
This is another case of chosen identity for this episode; like Sam and Arya, Dany has decided to commit to her nature – she is a conqueror, not a ruler. As Daario said moments before, she isn’t meant to sit pretty in the high tower and reason with people – she’s meant to swoop in and take what is hers. However, unlike Sam and Arya – this isn’t an instance of embracing an ethical identity: maybe Dany isn’t the hero she believes herself to be. Can a conqueror ever be truly considered benevolent? I think she’s more like her Mad King father than she knows – it could easily have been Dany in Bran’s vision, commanding her minions to “burn them all!” instead of King Aerys.
Next week: Sansa already tripping over her own feet trying
to out-Littlefinger Littlefinger